the idiot who keeps believing in luck


Earning my advanced social science degree and all I wrote was this stupid blog post

Wednesday, November 4, 2009

Most who know me well know that I'm an admitted news junkie. That said, I'll preface this blog post by saying I don't plan to write a lot about politics or current events here. If you want to talk politics I'd be more than happy to buy you a cup of coffee and discuss elections or healthcare or whatever. But I'll leave those conversations to the coffeehouse chat and not the blog.

Nonetheless, I do from time to time muse about where I get my news from. Newspapers and news magazines, political blogs—heck, even Twitter has become a legitimate news source these days.

But right now I want to focus on the major television news networks: CNN, Fox News, CBS, ABC, MSNBC, and PBS. They are the most immediate and accessible news sources for the most Americans—so it seems their quality of reporting should be the best.

Note how I intentionally and painfully abstained from sarcasm just then.

Now it may be partly due to my new job—where I spend hours at a time working with a multitude of psychological assessments that measure various dimensions of human nature—but I feel like we need a method to quickly and roughly compare the all around caliber of these news networks.

So I'd like to introduce into the completely nonexistent field of news assessment a new measurement of my own design. I have tentatively titled it

The Jon and Kate Battery of Stature

The “J/K B.S.” operates on the following assumptions:
  1. News sources will, from time to time, provide news coverage to the existential imbroglio that is the marriage of Jon and Kate Gosselin
  2. Varying news sources will cover Jon and Kate in varying degrees (depth, scope, and sheer volume of unnecessary reporting)
  3. Those news sources who cover Jon and Kate the most are probably the least deserving of your time and mine
Thus, we can expect an inverse relationship between the amount of Jon and Kate coverage and the overall quality of news.

I've operationalized and applied the J/K B.S. to the aforementioned news networks by searching their websites for the phrase “jon and kate” with the following results.
  1. PBS News – 10 results
  2. CBS News – 71 results
  3. CNN – 187 results
  4. ABC News – 365 results
  5. MSNBC - 32,90o results
  6. Fox News – 397,709 results
I'd like to think that this assessment of Stature might approximate the quality of journalism across American television. It suggests face validity, however more quantitative investigation may be appropriate.

P. S. – I strongly recommend The NewsHour with Jim Lehrer on PBS if you only have one hour to spare for news. If you have two, I'd throw in the Daily Show and The Colbert Report for good measure.

This blog post is dedicated to Will, for guilting me back onto the blog-writing wagon.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Bravo! I can get behind this! KPT

Anonymous said...

J/K B.S. - love it...! -TRP

Post a Comment